Visit Josh Shahryar's column >>

JOSH SHAHRYARHome Page

Journalist / Human Rights Activist
Add To Watchlist
Articles Posted: 57; Links Seeded: 2
Member Since: 7/2009Last Seen: 11/24/2009

The Green Brief #16 (July 02)

advertisement

(This report has been compiled through reports by twitter users in Iran and aboard, as well as contacts inside and outside Iran. Media outlets have been credit where used. As reports coming from Iran cannot be fully authenticated, if the report confirms something, at best it confirms that several reliable twitter sources agreed upon it. If you want to follow my updates, my twitter account is @Iran_Translator)

Protests

1. Thousands of people gathered at Iran's Beheshte Zahra Cemetery, along with other smaller cemeteries, to mourn the people who have died in the protests. The numbers were hard to confirm, but various sources claimed somewhere between 10,000 – 15,000. Large numbers of Basijis were reported to have been stationed in and around Beheshte Zahra Cemetery, but no clashes were reported. Shopkeepers in Tabriz have reportedly stopped their strikes because of government intimidation and threats made by the Basijis.

2. Mousavi's Facebook page asked for protesters to form a human chain this Sunday – we could not confirm this through other sources. Meanwhile, about 120 women from the group "Mourning Mothers" gathered at Laleh Park again today and lit candles in memory of the fallen protesters. They have planned mass gatherings in Laleh, Andisheh and Mellat parks for July 4. Relatives of detainees yet again gathered in front of Evin Prison today and asked for the release of their loved ones.

Government

3. Hard-line Parliament members today again called on the Judiciary to prosecute Mousavi for allegedly breaking the law by calling for protests and for instigating violence. The call had been made in the past as well and several state-run newspapers have also made similar demands in the past few days. Unconfirmed reports from Qom and Khorasan indicate that more and more clerics are considering denouncing the government's actions; declaring the protests as legitimate.

4. Samareh Hashemi, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's campaign manager, told PressTV today that the SMS outage and cell phone service restrictions were put in place to "ensure security" during and after the election. He added that Mousavi wasn't really an opposition leader because "his views closely match those of the governments." Furthermore, he claimed that the candidates KNOW that the election was as impartial as any before, and that no voting fraud had taken place.

5. More international pressure is being mounted on Iran's Government. There will be an EU meeting next week where it is reported that member nations will consider pulling their ambassadors from Iran. Russia's foreign ministry announced today that Russia opposed international sanctions against Iran and that the election and its aftermath were Iran's internal issues that needed to be dealt with by Iranians, MosNews reported. A former Justice Minister of Canada, Irwin Cotler, has asked the international community to ban Ahmadinejad from entering their countries, Deutsche-Welle reported.

6. Al-Arabiya's website has stated that an Egyptian lawyer belonging to the Muslim Brotherhood, Mamdouh Ismail has filed a complaint in Egypt's Prosecutor General's Office. He has asked them to ban Ahmadinejad from entering Egypt next month to attend a diplomatic meeting. He has accused Ahmadinejad of winning the election erroneously and for insulting two of Prophet Mohammed's companions.

Arrests, killed:

7. Seven people were arrested in Qazvin today in connection with the protests. The head of Participation Front in Hormozgan Province, Mr. Ramezanpour, was also arrested. The government-owned media now claims that 20 people have died in the post-election protests. Real numbers are hard to obtain, but the number is reportedly much higher than what the Iranian media has reported. On a positive note, Iranian journalists Maryam Ameri and Omid Mohaddes were released from prison today in Tehran.

8. Saeed Hajjarian – a prominent politician and backer of Mousavi – is being said to be in deteriorating health. Hajjarian has diabetes – a very serious condition that requires daily care. Amnesty International today once again called upon the government to release Hajjarian. On Wednesday, Newsweek asked Iran for the immediate release of their reporter, Maziar Bahari, who was arrested on June 21, 2009. Newsweek rejected accusations by the Iranian media that Bahari had a hand in the post-election violence. Bahari has since been denied access to a lawyer.

9. Media reports of six protesters, reportedly hung in Evin Prison, were denied by the government. Iranian Student's News Agency reported via their website that the aforementioned individuals were accused of killing their spouses and other people. They made neither implications nor correlations with the "prisoners" and the post-election arrests.

10. Interpol today denied that the witness to Neda Agha-Soltan's death is wanted by the Interpol. They also denied receiving any requests from the Iranian government for his arrest. Iranian media and government have claimed that the witness, Arash Hejazi, was wanted by the Interpol. Unconfirmed reports suggest that the Iranian government's intelligence agencies as well as the Ministry of Islamic Guidance are compiling a list of Iranian journalists which will be barred from traveling abroad.

11. Reports of torture at Evin and other Iranian prisons are continuing to mount. Some sources claim that detainees are being beaten every night and others are being water-boarded with hot water in order to coerce confessions from them.

Statements

12. Yet another Ayatollah has joined the cause of the protesters. Ayatollah Bayat-Zanjani today said that the demand for justice and protesting for one's rights was legal. He also denounced the suppression of protesters and called the act illegitimate. He asked Mousavi to stand for justice and help people obtain their rights. Zanjani joins Ayatollahs Taheri, Ghaffari, Sanei and Montazeri in supporting the cause of the protesters. Karoubi again announced today that he would not recognize the current government and would continue to stand by the people in their quest for their rights – even if it took the rest of his life.

13. It has been reported that Rafsanjani, who is one of the Imams that lead Friday Prayers in Tehran's largest mosque, has declined to lead prayers there again. Last week, his spot was first filled by Khamenei, but Khamenei pulled out at the last minute leaving Ahmad Khatami to lead the prayers. Rafsanjani is not planning to attend this Friday's Prayers either.

Media

14. Parlemaan News website has been blocked by the government. The website was one of the only remaining sources of impartial news for the Iranian people. The government closed it after it posted several of Mousavi's statements and Khatami's criticism of the government. Parlemaan News – parlemaan means parliament in Persian – is the official news website of the Imam's Way faction of MP's in the Iranian Parliament. They had been warned last week by security forces and the Judiciary to restrict criticism of the government.

15. The BBC reported today that the Kingdom of Jordan had banned Iran's state-run Al-Alam and Press TV stations from broadcasting in Jordan and revoked their operating permits. Al-Alam broadcasts news in Arabic and Press TV is the main English language news channel of Iran. The latter today showed footage of what they called 'thugs attacking Basiji Headquarters in Tehran' – but the footage only showed several protesters chanting in front of the headquarters at an unspecified date. The recording didn't show any of the 'thugs' actually using any of Molotov cocktails they were holding.

COMMUNICATIONS

16. Even though SMS was back in Tehran yesterday, reports indicate that it has been cut-off once again. Sources indicated that they had asked twitter users from Tehran to NOT text each other using the service because it could be a ploy by the government to find dissidents. There are reports that Iran's main telecom companies were trained in China in "how to weed out dissidents using their data posted on the net," as well as monitoring and other techniques.

17. Although yesterday's news of four un-opened ballot boxes found in Shiraz couldn't be verified, reliable sources indicate that the Governor of Fars Province, where Shiraz is located, announced today that the boxes were from past elections. He added that they will be stored as National Documents. Mohammad Reza Nasab-Abdollahi, the journalist that broke the news, has been reportedly intimidated by the government and is being pressured to recant his report and deny the previous claim.

18. Chants of Allah o Akbar again echoed across Iran. Reports have suggested that dozens of people – in some cases the residents of entire apartment buildings – have been arrested by Basijis for chanting on their rooftops at night. Residents in Northern Tehran have also been warned that they should either stop chanting or risk losing their satellite antennas. Satellite antennas are illegal in the country, but widely owned by the public.

  • 16 Votes
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.

Back To Top

What's this?
Who's leading the conversation?
This visualization below allows you to see the impact that each user has on the current conversation. The top row contains the group of users who have had the most impact, the 2nd row the group of users who have had the 2nd most impact (et cetera). Users with similar impact are grouped together, and the average score of the group is shown to the left of the group. The author of the article is also shown on the left, in their corresponding group. Each user's score is based on the number of comments the user has made plus the number of votes their comments have received. The scores are calculated relative one another, so while their absolute value is not particularly important, their relative difference does indicate a larger difference in impact on the conversation.
14
7.6
4.6
{"commentId":7998759,"authorDomain":"greenbrief"}

Another long one, I suppose. Trying to somehow cut this thing short.

{"commentId":7998759,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"greenbrief"}
  • 4 votes
Reply#1 - Thu Jul 2, 2009 9:46 PM EDT
{"commentId":7999541,"authorDomain":"blessed-isles"}

Don't cut it short, Josh, every word is important. This is the best synopsis of the news on Iran available, in my opinion.

{"commentId":7999541,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"blessed-isles"}
  • 5 votes
#1.1 - Thu Jul 2, 2009 10:52 PM EDT
{"commentId":8000412,"authorDomain":"PamelaDrew"}
Don't cut it short, Josh, every word is important.

Absolutely, we have the mainstream to chop it to little sound bites, your reporting is priceless.

{"commentId":8000412,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"PamelaDrew"}
  • 4 votes
#1.2 - Fri Jul 3, 2009 12:28 AM EDT
{"commentId":8007565,"authorDomain":"gayshit"}
faggotDeleted
{"commentId":8008775,"authorDomain":"tyler"}

1.3 deleted, a user named faggot. You can imagine how great their post was. Banned.

...

This is nice and comprehensive, Josh Shahryar. Good stuff.

{"commentId":8008775,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"tyler"}
  • 3 votes
#1.4 - Fri Jul 3, 2009 4:33 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":7999031,"authorDomain":"paperdragon"}
Zanjani joins Ayatollahs Taheri, Ghaffari and Montazeri in their support for the cause of the protesters

What about Grand Ayatollah Sanei? he was reported to be siding with the reformists up until about a week ago, but I haven't heard anything about his since.

{"commentId":7999031,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"paperdragon"}
  • 4 votes
Reply#2 - Thu Jul 2, 2009 10:10 PM EDT
{"commentId":7999244,"authorDomain":"greenbrief"}

You're right. I put that in as well. He was the first one too. Too many Ayatollahs to keep track of in Iran, to be honest.

{"commentId":7999244,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"greenbrief"}
  • 4 votes
#2.1 - Thu Jul 2, 2009 10:29 PM EDT
{"commentId":8001799,"authorDomain":"paperdragon"}

Yeah. I say we just get rid of about half of them...

{"commentId":8001799,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"paperdragon"}
  • 2 votes
#2.2 - Fri Jul 3, 2009 5:37 AM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":7999552,"authorDomain":"Rainmaker"}

Josh, could you elaborate on the Muslim Brotherhood position with regard to Ahmadinejad's alleged insult to

two of the prophet's sahaba, companions, Talha ibn Obaidallah and al-Zobeir ibn al-Awam

Source: Al Arabiya

It does not appear clearly if Mahmoud Ahmadinejad did accuse the named followers of "apostasy and betrayal"? Accordint to Al Arabiya it's supposed to have taken place

in a campaign interview with Iran's Channel Three on June 10 Ahmadinejad

Can you confirm this?

If it is true, what would be the political purpose of such propaganda in Iran?

I assume the sahaba are of particular importance to Sunni. How important, and how seriously should we take Mahmoud Ismail's letter of complaint?

He seems to be a rather dubious figure himself, but that doesn't mean he cannot be influential. Do you know anything about his clout among Egyptians, Muslims in the region, worldwide?

{"commentId":7999552,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"Rainmaker"}
  • 5 votes
Reply#3 - Thu Jul 2, 2009 10:54 PM EDT
{"commentId":8001784,"authorDomain":"greenbrief"}

Well, first of, Shi'ites and Sunnis are divided on a single and very important issue. The issue is simple: After Mohammed's death, should Muslims have followed Mohammed's teachings or should they've follow his family members?

Shi'ites believe the latter while Sunnis agree with the former. Shi'ites accuse prominent Sahabis like Omar, Abu Bakr, Othman, Zubair bin Al-Awam and Talha bin Obaidullah of stealing the leadership of Muslims from Mohammed's family who was led by Ali after his death and, thus, don't like them very much. Like really isn't the word ... hate's a more proper word. So it's not really surprising that Ahmadinejad said what he did. As a matter of fact, it's quite normal.

As for whether Ismail should be taken seriously, I think we should at least pay some attention to it. Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood has some ties to Hezbollah and Hamas - although you might find evidence to the contrary as well - and since Ahmadinejad is a staunch supporter of Hamas and Hezbollah, it seems quite puzzling as to why Ismail would do such a thing. It definitely is very interesting.

{"commentId":8001784,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"greenbrief"}
  • 3 votes
#3.1 - Fri Jul 3, 2009 5:29 AM EDT
{"commentId":8001963,"authorDomain":"Rainmaker"}

So it's not really surprising that Ahmadinejad said what he did. As a matter of fact, it's quite normal.

it seems quite puzzling as to why Ismail would do such a thing. It definitely is very interesting.

Thanks Josh, that was very enlightening, even if Ismail's motive remains a mystery.

Douglas Farah has this relatively updated profile of Muslim Brotherhood's role in the Shia-Sunni conflict:

The Brotherhood has mediated or attempted to mediate a host of disputes between Shiite and Sunnis, including the unsuccessful efforts by the International Muslim Brotherhood's Yousef Nada to negotiate an end to the Iran-Iraq war.

One of the biggest bones on contention between the MB in Iraq and the al Qaeda groups of Zarqawi was the latter's insistence on targeting Shiite groups, while the MB units viewed that as a far lower priority than targeting the Americans.

The understanding of the structure of the Muslim Brotherhood has often been misunderstood in the United States, where it is often viewed as Egyptian organization. The international structure is largely ignored. It is also worth remembering (although it seldom is) that Hamas is, according to its own statutes-article 2-an organic part of the Muslim Brotherhood.

It would seem Ismail's move indicates a turn towards the Al Qaeda side of the argument. I've noticed frequent reports about the US withdrawal of troops from Iraq, a peculiar tight lipped response from Iraqi MPs to the Iranian election, and on top of it a newly published report says Saddam made up WMD claims out of fear of Iranian invasion.

Perhaps Ahmadinejad's militant version of Iran would be too grave a threat to Muslim Brotherhood interests. It could be a case of dividing the spoil before the bear is caught and making sure Iran doesn't take the lion's share to grossly contaminate metaphors.

{"commentId":8001963,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"Rainmaker"}
  • 3 votes
#3.2 - Fri Jul 3, 2009 6:43 AM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":8005320,"authorDomain":"rita-canuck"}

today: Hashem Khastar, Reza Arab, Roohollah Shahsavar & many civilians are still detained in Mashhad.

today: In a short call from prison, Mojtaba Tehrani, asked his family for prayers, said he's in good physical condition.

Link to video: "Iran Media Caught Lying and Deceiving People under Torture" #/video/video.php?v=1021248871930

{"commentId":8005320,"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952","authorDomain":"rita-canuck"}
  • 2 votes
Reply#4 - Fri Jul 3, 2009 12:34 PM EDT
{"canLink":false,"threadId":"618303","isPrivate":false}
Leave a Comment:
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
{"threadId":"618303","contentId":"2992952"}
Start TrackingStart Tracking
Stop TrackingStop Tracking